Calypso Cay

by Nina Fredrizzi

My friend J.P. loves Sirius Satellite Radio’s Margaritaville Channel. He’s pretty convinced that Margaritaville is the only channel on satellite radio, and he lugged his Sirius boom box thousands of miles on vacation to the Caribbean so he could hear Jimmy Buffet playing in his natural habitat.  When he’s working on his boat, J.P. will connect a string of electric cords from the house to his radio so he can listen to Margaritaville at edge of the dock—200 yards away.
           

It won’t be long before Parrotheads like JP start flocking to the new Calypso Cay Restaurant in Brewerton, which opened officially July 21st.  With a waterfront view of the Oneida River, bars chock-full with cold beer and margaritas and—of course—Jimmy Buffet blaring in the background, Calypso Cay promises a considerable departure from your average CNY dining experience, no airfare required.
          

  Bringing a taste of the tropics to customers is nothing new for Calypso Cay’s owner, Patrick Hartough, who used to own a travel agency.  Located on Dockside Drive, to the left of the Route 11 Bridge in Brewerton, Calypso is every inch the low-key Caribbean getaway.  A sandy, nautical display, and a faux palm tree in the entranceway, greet patrons as they wend their way up the restaurant’s driveway.  Inside, polished wood accents meet the serene blue and yellow hues of the tropics in a simple, clean décor that suits Calypso’s beachy, open-air vibe. The restaurant’s young, friendly staff is outfitted in blue Hawaiian-print sarongs, and scurries back and forth through Calypso’s bustling rooms and its two full-service bars. 

Even on a Tuesday when I visited, Calypso was packed to the gills with guests eager to take advantage of the balmy summer night.  Your best bet when planning a visit is to call ahead and reserve a spot at one of the restaurant’s twelve outdoor umbrella tables.  There’s little that’s formal about Calypso’s waterfront, where guests sit on bar stools and help themselves to condiments contained in empty Landshark beer boxes.  But that’s what makes it so much fun. There’s also little about the view that’s less than stellar - a view that’s only enhanced by the addition of an electric blue palm tree, burning brightly against the horizon as twilight slips slowly into dusk.
Calypso hasn’t forgotten about its sea-faring patrons either, and several slips allow Oneida River boaters to tie up for dinner. Hartough plans to expand the restaurant’s boat-friendly atmosphere by offering take-out delivered directly to slips—along with a bucket of beers, if requested.  There are also plans for the addition of live music, and deck-side grilling, so guests can see and smell their entrees being prepared in front of them. 
On the whole, Calypso’s menu is just what you’d expect from a beachside restaurant, offering a selection of quality seafood, burgers, and kabobs from the grill. 

As an appetizer, the garlic and ale clam steamers are rich and tender, their flavor heightened by a rich reduction of diced plum tomatoes, scallions and garlic. 
Calypso offers two Island Burger specials (both under $10) including a blue crab burger and a calypso jerk burger, slathered with a Caribbean jerk sauce and topped with a thick wedge of pineapple, whose juicy sweetness pairs well with the tangy heat of the jerk.

Other original sandwiches include the Malibu coconut fish po-boy with mango salsa ($7.95), and a lobster and seafood wrap with Caribbean-seasoned mayo ($10.95). 
For the main course, entrée-sized portions of clam and mussel steamers are available ($16-$17) along with chicken and steak, shrimp scampi, yellow-fin tuna, and haddock ($14-$20). 
Entrees come with soup or salad, and a choice of sides like fries, pasta, baked beans, or slaw. 
My pick?  The Duchess Island potatoes are all butter-soaked, bacon-sprinkled, cheesy-melted goodness and definitely worth the headache they’ll give your nutritionist when she finds out. 
Just tell her you were on vacation.  
 

Calypso Cay Restaurant
11 Dockside Drive
Brewerton, NY 13029
(315) 668-5108

 

 

 

 

Back to Top